5 Rare Coins You Should Keep in 2025

Coins have long held an allure, with certain nickels, dimes, quarters, and other denominations fetching far more than their face value due to rarity and historical significance.

The more uncommon a coin is, the greater its potential value. Over time, the value of these coins can appreciate significantly, making them a valuable asset for collectors or even casual finders.

The $8 Million Rare Bicentennial Quarter- Still Circulating Today

Before diving into appraisals, it’s essential to confirm whether the coin is worth the effort, as professional coin appraisals can be costly.

For those unsure, conducting a quick online search could help determine whether your old coins are worth a considerable amount. Here’s a look at some particularly valuable coins that could be hiding in your collection or change jar.

1. 1913 Liberty Head Nickel

A Rare Find

The 1913 Liberty Head Nickel is one of the most coveted and rare coins in American numismatic history. With only five known to exist, this coin is a true gem. In fact, two of these rare coins are privately held and unlikely to be seen by the public again.

The Lincoln Wheat Penny Worth $20 Million – Still Circulating Today

The Eliasberg specimen holds the record for the highest PCGS grade (PR66), having fetched $1.48 million in 1996. It was resold in 2001 for approximately $1.84 million, and again in 2005, it went for $4.15 million. Most recently, it was sold in 2007 for a stunning $5 million.

While you might not possess this specific coin, you could still be in possession of similar pieces that may be worth far more than the face value.

2. 1794 Flowing Hair Dollar

A Piece of U.S. History

The 1794 Flowing Hair Dollar is another exceptional coin, with only around 150 to 200 known to exist today. Minted between 1794 and 1795, the coin’s design was created by Robert Scot and features Lady Liberty on the front, with an eagle framed by a wreath on the reverse.

The Rare Bicentennial Quarter Worth $66K That’s Still Circulating

This coin was eventually replaced by the Draped Bust dollar. The PCGS lists the 1794 Flowing Hair Dollar as extremely rare, with one of these coins selling for an astounding $6.6 million. Other examples from the same series have fetched anywhere from several thousand dollars to over $100,000 at auction.

3. 1940s Mercury Dime

A Noteworthy Find

While not as valuable as some other coins, the 1940s Mercury Dime remains a significant find for collectors. Produced between 1916 and 1945, approximately 21.5 million of these dimes were minted.

Designed by Adolph Alexander Weinman, the Mercury Dime features a youthful Liberty wearing a winged cap on the front, with the reverse showing an olive branch surrounding a fasces. These coins have sold for as much as $8,519 at auction, making them an excellent find for anyone with a collection of older coins.

4. Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle

A Classic Gold Coin

The Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle was initially valued at $20 and was minted between 1907 and 1933. Named after its designer, the renowned sculptor Augustus Saint-Gaudens, the coin features Lady Liberty holding a torch and an olive branch, with the sun setting behind her.

The reverse shows an eagle soaring before a sun. Notably, some of these coins were minted without the inscription “In God We Trust.” For the 1907 version of this coin, a PCGS grade 68 could fetch approximately $300,000, while an MS67 version has an auction record of $276,000.

5. 1909-S Indian Head Penny

A Rare and Valuable Penny

The 1909-S Indian Head Penny is one of the rarest pennies, with fewer than 300,000 minted. Designed by James Barton Longacre, the coin features a profile of Lady Liberty wearing a feathered headdress, with the reverse showcasing a laurel wreath surrounding the words “One Cent.”

These coins, which were part of the Indian Cent series (1859-1909), have become highly collectible. In 2021, one of these pennies sold for $3,400 at auction, though certain higher-grade examples may fetch even more.

Value Estimates for Rare Coins

Many old coins, particularly those with historical significance or low mintage, can be worth far more than their face value. Whether you’ve stumbled upon a 1913 Liberty Head Nickel, a 1794 Flowing Hair Dollar, or a 1909-S Indian Head Penny, you may be holding a valuable piece of history in your hands.

If you think you might have a rare coin, it’s worth checking its potential value—just be sure to do some research or consult with an expert before spending money on an appraisal.

FAQ

What makes a coin valuable?

A coin’s rarity, historical significance, and condition are all factors that influence its value. Coins that are no longer in circulation or were produced in limited quantities tend to be more valuable.

How can I determine the value of my coin?

You can check online resources, visit local dealers, or seek professional appraisals to determine your coin’s worth. Online auction sites often provide insight into recent sale prices for similar coins.

What should I do if I find a rare coin?

Before selling or appraising, do thorough research to ensure the coin’s authenticity and potential value. It’s also a good idea to consult with a numismatist for an accurate evaluation.